Back to Learning Hub
E-commerce•10 min read•November 6, 2026

Black Friday Sale Ideas: 8 Offers and What They Cost

Black Friday sale ideas for an online store, each priced on margin: percent off, thresholds, multi-buys, bundles, gifts, and the EU and UK price rules.

W

Wilmer

Co-founder & CEO

Black Friday Sale Ideas: 8 Offers and What They Cost

Most lists of black friday sale ideas stop at the headline: 25 percent off, buy one get one, a free gift. What decides whether the weekend makes money is what each offer does to the margin on every order, and how many extra orders it needs to pay for itself, so this guide prices eight offer formats on the same invented product before you pick one for 27 November 2026.


The short answer: price each offer on margin first, then read the results in Arktis


The best Black Friday sale for most online stores is not the deepest discount but an offer that raises the order: a spend threshold, a multi-buy, a bundle or a gift with purchase. On our example product, 25 percent off one item leaves $22.20 of contribution per order and needs 87 percent more orders to earn what full price earns, while $20 off orders over $150 leaves $71.80 on a two-item order, a margin of 51.3 percent against 52 percent at full price. Work out break-even ROAS for each offer before launch, and in the EU check that any percentage is calculated from your lowest price in the previous 30 days.


For reading the results, Arktis is the clear winner for an online store. Give each offer its own UTM campaign and Arktis counts conversions per campaign and per ad platform from Shopify orders matched back to a visit, and its Revenue page shows revenue net of refunds by source, so orders refunded after the weekend come out of the total. Plans are $49, $149 and $349 a month, and Growth, which adds session recordings and conversion tracking and goals, has a 7-day free trial.


Offer (example $80 product)Customer paysContribution per orderContribution marginBreak-even ROAS
Full price, one item$80$41.6052.0%1.92
15 percent off, one item$68$29.9644.1%2.27
25 percent off, one item$60$22.2037.0%2.70
40 percent off, one item$48$10.5622.0%4.55
Buy one, get one half price$120 for two$52.4043.7%2.29
$20 off orders over $150$140 for two$71.8051.3%1.95
Bundle of three for $200$200 for three$102.0051.0%1.96
Gift with purchase (gift costs $6)$80$35.6044.5%2.25

Key takeaways


A price cut on a single item takes margin away faster than it looks: on a product with a 52 percent contribution margin, 25 percent off removes almost half the contribution, and 40 percent off removes three quarters of it. Offers that ask for a bigger basket spread the shipping cost over more items and keep the margin close to full price. In the EU a percentage off has to be measured from the lowest price of at least the previous 30 days, and in the UK a reference price has to be genuine and "free" has to mean free.


The example behind the numbers


Every figure here uses one invented product so the offers can be compared. It sells for $80, costs $28 landed and $8 per order to pick, pack and ship, and payment fees take 3 percent of what the customer pays. At full price that leaves $41.60 of contribution, a margin of 52 percent, so break-even ROAS is 1 divided by 0.52, or 1.92. Returns are left out to keep the arithmetic readable, and they push every break-even point higher; our guide to ecommerce returns explains what a return costs.


The definitions follow our guides to contribution margin and break-even ROAS. Put in your own costs before deciding.


Black Friday sale ideas, priced


Percentage off sitewide


The simplest offer and the most expensive per order. At 25 percent off, the product sells for $60, contribution falls from $41.60 to $22.20, and break-even ROAS rises from 1.92 to 2.70. To earn the same total contribution as at full price you need 1.87 times as many orders. At 15 percent off the damage is smaller: $29.96 per order and a break-even ROAS of 2.27. It pays when it brings in customers who would not otherwise have bought, and costs most when buyers would have bought in December anyway.


A deep discount on a short list


Some stores run 40 percent off a handful of products. On our example that leaves $10.56 of contribution and needs 3.94 times as many orders to match full price. It makes sense for stock you need to clear, where the money is already spent and holding it costs more. A deep discount on best sellers mostly gives margin to people who were going to buy.


A spend threshold


"$20 off orders over $150" rewards the basket rather than the item. A customer who buys two of our products, $160 of goods, pays $140, and because the items ship together the order leaves $71.80 of contribution, a margin of 51.3 percent and a break-even ROAS of 1.95. The effective discount is 12.5 percent per item, given only on larger orders. Set the threshold just above your current average order value: one that few shoppers reach does little, and one below today's average discounts orders you were already getting.


Buy one, get one half price


A multi-buy gives the discount only when the customer takes a second unit. Two products for $120 is the same 25 percent per item as a sitewide 25 percent off, but the order carries one shipping cost instead of two and no single-item order is discounted. Contribution is $52.40, a margin of 43.7 percent, and break-even ROAS is 2.29.


Bundles


A bundle of three for $200, against $240 bought separately, is 16.7 percent off per item. It leaves $102.00 of contribution, a margin of 51 percent and a break-even ROAS of 1.96, close to full price, because three items share one shipment. Bundles work best when the products genuinely go together, a set, a starter kit, a gift box.


Gift with purchase


A gift that costs you $6 changes no price at all. The order still pays $80, contribution falls to $35.60, and break-even ROAS rises only to 2.25. It works with something cheap to make and appealing to receive, such as a travel size or a sample of a new line.


Free shipping over a threshold


For a store that normally charges $6 for delivery, unlike our example, waiving it on an $80 order is a hidden discount worth 7.5 percent of the item price. Tied to a threshold above your average order value, it behaves like a spend threshold. Shopify lists free shipping, amount off and buy X get Y as its standard discount types, and points to apps, or Checkout Blocks on Plus, for tiered discounts.


Early access instead of a deeper discount


Giving subscribers the same offer a day early costs nothing extra in margin or ads. Our Black Friday email guide covers the sequence, and the Black Friday marketing strategy covers building the list.


How deep the market will go in 2026


Adobe's forecast, published on 28 September 2026, expects US online discounts of up to 30 percent off listed price during Cyber Week, up to 14 percent in early November and up to 21 percent just before Thanksgiving, with electronics peaking at 30 percent, toys at 29 percent and apparel at 23 percent. Those are peaks across many retailers, not a target.


EU and UK rules on price reductions


This section describes what the rules say; it is not legal advice.


The EU: the lowest price in the previous 30 days


Article 6a of Directive 98/6/EC, inserted by Directive (EU) 2019/2161 and applied from 28 May 2022, says any announcement of a price reduction must indicate the prior price, the lowest price the trader applied in a period of not less than 30 days before the reduction. In September 2024 the Court of Justice ruled in the Aldi Süd case that a reduction announced as a percentage must be calculated from that lowest price. If you ran 15 percent off at any point in the 30 days before your Black Friday prices start, Black Friday's 25 percent is measured from that sale price.


The Commission's guidance says a general announcement such as 20 percent off everything is allowed, with the prior price shown on each product's price in the online shop. It puts conditional offers, such as buy one get two, outside Article 6a, though they remain subject to the rules on unfair practices. Member States may let a reduction that deepens without interruption during one sale be measured from the price before it began, but the Commission says separate Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions within 30 days do not count as one sale, so each is measured from the lowest price in the 30 days before it, and details vary by country.


The UK: genuine reference prices and real "free"


For England, Scotland and Wales, the Chartered Trading Standards Institute's Guidance for Traders on Pricing Practices, updated in April 2026, judges a "was" price by how long and how recently it was charged, where, and whether significant sales were made at it. It says volume offers such as buy one get one free should only be used if the customer genuinely gets better value.


Schedule 20 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, in force since 6 April 2025, bans outright falsely stating that a product, or an offer on it, is available only for a limited time in order to rush the customer into a decision, and describing something as free if the customer pays anything beyond the unavoidable cost of responding and of collection or delivery, which matters for a gift with purchase.


What to measure, offer by offer


Give each offer its own UTM campaign name, and each email, ad and post its own utm_content, with the UTM builder. Then measure orders, contribution per order rather than revenue, units per order, and the share of buyers who were new customers. The first two say whether the offer paid, the third whether a threshold or multi-buy lifted the basket, and the fourth whether the discount bought new customers or gave margin to existing ones. Check the same buyers again at 30, 60 and 90 days; our guide to repeat purchase rate covers the method.


Measuring the offers in Arktis


Arktis matches Shopify orders, which arrive by webhook from the day the store connects, back to a visit: on email where the store has identified the visitor, otherwise on the UTM source of a session from the previous 24 hours, which can be another visitor's session. Conversions are counted per UTM campaign and per ad platform, and the Campaign Performance section on the Data page shows the ten UTM campaigns with the most conversions and breaks campaigns down by utm_content, so offers with their own campaign names sit side by side.


The Revenue page shows revenue net of refunds, orders and paying customers by the source each order was matched to, over preset ranges, so a fully refunded order drops out. On Growth and above, recordings of consenting visitors can be filtered to those who converted and to sessions that included a given page, such as the bundle page.


Where this approach and Arktis fall short


The arithmetic here measures what each order earns, not what the offer caused. A discount that brings forward a December purchase looks like a win on the weekend and a loss a month later. A store with very thin margins may find that no discount clears its break-even line, and the honest answer is a gift, early access or no sale at all.


Arktis does not run discounts and has no A/B testing, so it cannot split traffic between two offers. It holds no costs per product or per offer, only the store-wide cost percentages you set, so contribution per offer is your calculation from its order counts. There is no bulk import of Shopify orders placed before the store connects, and orders completed inside another app's checkout usually arrive unmatched and appear under Direct on the Revenue page.


Price the offer, then measure it


To see conversions per offer from your own Shopify orders through Cyber Monday, start the 7-day Growth trial, or compare plans on the pricing page. Put your own margin into the ROAS calculator before launch, build the page with our Black Friday landing page guide, and run the Black Friday tracking checklist before the first order.


Sources

EUR-Lex: Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Article 6a of Directive 98/6/EC on the prior price and the application date of 28 May 2022, accessed 2 November 2026

European Commission: guidance on the interpretation and application of Article 6a, general price reduction announcements, conditional offers outside its scope and successive Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions, published 29 December 2021, accessed 2 November 2026

Court of Justice of the EU: press release 152/24, Aldi Süd, percentage reductions calculated from the lowest price in the previous 30 days, published 26 September 2024

Business Companion: CTSI Guidance for Traders on Pricing Practices, reference prices, volume offers and use of free, updated April 2026, accessed 2 November 2026

legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20, paragraphs 7 and 23 on false limited-time claims and free, in force from 6 April 2025, accessed 2 November 2026

Adobe: 2026 holiday shopping forecast, expected discount depth by period and category, published 28 September 2026

Shopify Help Center: discount types, amount off, buy X get Y and free shipping discounts, accessed 2 November 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What are good Black Friday sale ideas for a small online store?

Offers that raise the order rather than cut the price of one item usually leave the most margin: a spend threshold such as $20 off orders over $150, a multi-buy, a bundle or a gift with purchase. Early access for email subscribers costs nothing extra in margin. Price each one on contribution margin and break-even ROAS before launch, and keep sitewide percentages for when they bring in genuinely new customers.

How much does a 25 percent Black Friday discount cost in margin?

It depends on your costs, but it is usually more than 25 percent of the profit. On an $80 product with $28 product cost, $8 shipping and 3 percent payment fees, contribution falls from $41.60 to $22.20 per order, and break-even ROAS rises from 1.92 to 2.70. The store needs 87 percent more orders to earn the same total contribution as at full price.

Is buy one get one half price better than a percentage discount?

Per item it can be the same discount: two $80 items for $120 is 25 percent off each. The difference is that the discount is only given when the customer takes a second unit, and the two items share one shipment, so the order earns more. In the example in this guide, the two-item order leaves $52.40 of contribution, against $44.40 for the same two items sold as two separate orders at 25 percent off.

What price must a Black Friday discount be measured from in the EU?

Article 6a of the Price Indication Directive requires an announced price reduction to show the prior price, which is the lowest price the trader applied in at least the 30 days before the reduction. The Court of Justice ruled in September 2024 that a percentage reduction must be calculated from that price. A promotion you ran in the 30 days before the Black Friday price starts therefore lowers the reference for a Black Friday percentage.

How do I measure which Black Friday offer worked?

Give each offer its own UTM campaign and compare orders, contribution per order, units per order and the share of new customers, then check repeat purchases at 30, 60 and 90 days. Arktis counts conversions per UTM campaign and per ad platform from Shopify orders matched back to a visit, and shows revenue net of refunds by source. Product costs come from your own figures, since Arktis holds no costs per product or per offer.

Try Arktis free for 7 days

Attribution tracking, session recordings, and AI automation in one platform. Set up in 2 minutes, free for 7 days.

Start 7-day free trial

Written by

W

Wilmer

Co-founder & CEO

Wilmer leads product strategy at Arktis, focusing on privacy-first analytics and attribution tracking for e-commerce brands.